cathyse97 via flickr

How has this not become an unacceptable symbol in our society? How is it that people are allowed to use some bullshit excuse of “heritage” or “pride” regarding this? I’d compare it to Nazism and swastikas but that’s really lost it’s meaning with the banal, ad nauseum usage they receive and because no one needs to prove Godwin’s Law to make this point. So how is it that elected officials who are, at least in theory, supposed to represent all his or her constituents allowed to embrace such a hateful and divisive symbol?

Virginian Governor Bob McDonnell, who has already shown his Commonwealth what he thinks of its gay constituents, has now proclaimed that this April is “Confederate History Month.” Now had this been a solemn proclamation instead of a dog-whistle celebration it would be fine, even encouraged. If “Confederate History Month” was meant to highlight the crimes of slavery, the bloody waste that was perpetrated to try and save it, and a reason for Black and white communities to come together and try to erase those divisions that are still with us today, I would applaud it. However, Governor McDonnell’s original proclamation did not even mention slavery but instead called the Confederacy, “this defining chapter in Virginia’s history.” Really? Of all the things that Virginia could be defined for in the history of the country you chose this? When asked why a “Confederate History Month” would exclude any mention of slavery, McDonnell responded, “there were any number of aspects to that conflict between the states. Obviously, it involved slavery. It involved other issues. But I focused on the ones I thought were most significant for Virginia.” I suppose this shouldn’t be surprising as McDonnell chose to adorn his campaign booth at a gun show in 2009 with the Stars and Bars.

What is perhaps even more alarming is that McDonnell appears not to be an aberration. Indeed both Mississippi and Georgia have Confederate History proclamations that do not include mentions of slavery. With our country’s first African-American president and next year being the 150th anniversary of the beginning of the Civil War, we should be on the lookout for even more references to secession, the Confederacy, and dog-whistle politics. The Confederacy is not something we should proud of and its symbols should not be given respect. But we should also not forget them, we need to remember it and learn from it, but never allow celebrations of it. McDonnell has since added a reference to slavery in his proclamation which is a step in the right direction but the romanticization that saturates the rest of it should disgust us all.

4 Responses to "The Confederate Flag is an Anti-Human Symbol of Hate"

Steeleagle says

The confederate Battle Flag was raised to fight for independence against taxes, union laws from the industrial north. Both the North and South both housed slaves. Abraham Lincoln was raised by them and Gen. Robert E. Lee never owned one. Every slave that was brought over to this country were brought abort ships bearing the United States flag, not the Confederate flag. The idiots that call themselves the KKK also fly an United States flag and carry a cross. Neither of those two objects are considered hate symbols. Anyone that is offended by the confederate battle flag really needs a history lesson.

fwoan says

Hey username Steeleagle! Did you know that “Steel Eagle” pulls up some pretty interesting white-supremacist links in a search engine? I didn’t until a few moments ago! Speaking of search engines, using your email address pulls up all sorts of stuff about you including highschool reunion information, your phone number, and your personal myspace account (nice tattoos!) – so while you’re free to opine on your affection for the confederate flag, I’d encourage you not to do so in such public a manner.

Anyways, welcome to a post written six months ago! You’d think with all that time you’d have made your way to the comments section where Jack and I already mentioned that the American flag absolutely is a symbol of hate. Let’s just finish off and state absolutely that crosses are hate symbols as well! Any flag or symbol used as an excuse to murder or subjugate one’s fellow human beings can and should be held as a hate symbol – the one you’re defending, username Steeleagle, just had the added bonus of wanting to continue the practice of buying and selling human beings like property.

That aside, I couldn’t give less of a shit about the points you’re trying to make about who owned slaves and who didn’t or how the U.S. did terrible things too, etc. This isn’t a blog about defending the U.S. if you’ll take the time to notice. While I applaud Mr. Lincoln’s (convenient) ending of the practice of slavery, he never would have had the bigots of the Confederacy not risen up and forced his hand – so I wont spend much time defending him or his obvious opportunism.

So to sum up, because you’ve already demonstrated that your reading comprehension leaves much to be desired: 1) You’re wrong about why that war was fought and no one cares about your revisionism, 2) I don’t care who had slaves. Lincoln and Lee would have been happy to see human objectification continue and were power brokers of the status quo. Finally, 3) THIS ISN’T EVEN THE POINT OF THE POST.

Okay, go back to posting hunting pictures of yourself on myspace.

Comments are closed.