Yesterday, despite multiple campaigns to have actual public opinion legislated with regards to healthcare, Washington ultimately decided that our country needs to reward to the private insurance industry that has so ruthlessly broken our health system with a mandate for all Americans to purchase insurance. Uninsured Americans will be criminalized with punitive fines of about 2% of their wages and we will have to start paying for a product that many of us will not be able to afford to use. Let’s be honest about this, this is a tax paid to private corporations who only received this prize because of how badly they have handled their position this far.
To be serious, the outcome we are now faced with is unsurprising. In the current political climate when politicians will be gearing up for reelection at a time when corporations are free to give as much as they wish, it should be unsurprising to anyone who wonders why our voices are silenced in favor of theirs. We will continue to see more and more blatant examples of this because our representatives are no longer beholden to us.
President Obama who campaigned against an individual mandate, and campaigned for a public option has instead done everything in his power to ensure otherwise. Right away, the country was bombarded with a message campaign telling us that “single-payer” healthcare was dead and nothing could bring it back, but the reasons for this were never clearly laid out (making it quite obvious that the corporate masters of these politicians forbade it). Obama was immediately caught negotiating a deal with the pharmaceutical industry that clearly laid out what he was willing to give up. Even when it came to the public option, the president was never willing to defend it with anything more than words that ultimately proved false. Even his own damn plan neglected to include a public option!
During this horribly long debate we have seen several members of congress (Republicans aside, because who seriously listened to them besides the Tea Party?) give varying opinions on what should be included. However the only time the White House thought to take action was when it was a progressive voice asking for the public’s wishes to be respected. The Blue Dogs were never chastised, never had the president deriding them in their districts. No, they got deals like Nelson and medieval amendments like Stupak. Those that worked to weaken the bill or make it more corporate friendly were rewarded for their efforts, so much so that liberals started thinking that it was the only way to win. Liberals went from rightly calling for the bill to be killed to timidly backing it as an important “first step”. When people like Kucinich refused to settle Markos Moulitsas went on television to threaten a primary challenge! Liberals went from wanting to start over to wanting more corporate-friendly Democrats elected. The campaign has been a truly awesome display of fracturing the liberals, when they should have been the left’s greatest ally.
Another sad display of the fracturing our electorate suffered during this campaign by corporate interests was the Tea Party movement. So misinformed were these people that they helped provide the illusion of controversy surrounding publicly funded healthcare when in fact it was heavily supported. This group of people who showed their willingness to campaign and protest should have been subjected to a more comprehensive education campaign by the left and liberals instead of turning them into a spectacle (of which I am guilty at times, too). Educating them would not have destroyed their energy regarding the subject but would have diverted it to a solution that was in our mutual self-interest.
I had wanted to wait until after this mess was done to write about healthcare reform again and it appears the time has come. So now as we ready our checkbooks for the tribute payments required of us to maintain an industry whose very existence is perpetuated by refusing the service it exists to offer, think on all the lies and tricks we have been subjected to. Maybe Obama will be willing to solve the homeless crisis by mandating that we all buy a house or maybe solve the hunger crisis by simply requiring us to buy enough food to keep us fat and happy. These plans, like our “healthcare reform” plan is, in the words of Rahm Emmanuel, fucking retarded.
BONUS: firedoglake has provided a great .pdf regarding the myths of this bill. I have hosted it for your download here: Healthcare Reform Myth Fact-Check.
Great synopsis of the HCR debacle. Thanks.
Ugh.
I am so disgusted with how this turned out. We protect and subsidize so many broken, outdated, destructive business models; private/for-profit health insurance being one of the largest and most egregious examples.
I didn’t vote for Obama (Nader) and I usually try to find a democratic-socialist or labor-oriented candidate in the down-ticket races. I am a registered Green. However, I did allow myself to become somewhat romanticized by Obama during the election. Some part of me really thought (hoped?) that we were electing a historic leader. I cannot fairly articulate my degree of disappointment, and we’re not even two years into this adminstration. I still have difficulty comprehending how badly this nation was bait-and-switched by this administration and this Congress.
There were a lot of different things I wanted to say in this comment. I had a rants about predatory capitalism vs democratic socialism; about the immorality of for-profit health insurance; about the commons and the social safety net.
I’ve scrapped all that now, in favor of this one sentiment:
The eventual undoing of this once-great nation will be directly correlatable to our two-party, winner-take-all system of electing our government officials. We have distilled a complex, nuanced political world into a simplistic, binary choice: A or B, Red or Blue, Republican or Democrat. Real life is rarely so simple; politics never is.
We choose our party as if it were a sports team or our favorite brand of car; and no one wants to vote for a loser, right? This sad nation is locked into “lesser evil” voting, making it nearly impossible for third party candidates to reach viability in large-scale elections.
Additionally, our winner take all elections leave dissenting voters feeling disenfranchised and without a stake in their government. This causes more people to either: Join one of the “winning” teams, or disengage with politics altogether. Either outcome is favorable to the establishment.
So they just keep us spinning, reacting to the incumbents with misdirected rage, putting the other side back in for another round. Things keep getting worse, but few have the ability or willingness to see why: On policy, both parties are 95% the same. They only differ around the edges, on wedge issues and meaningless red herrings. On the most important and substantive matters, they are fully Corporatist.
And even when they do seem to differ on a major policy, we give them a chance and they end up being no different at all. Obama, the current Congress and health insurance reform are a perfect example of this. We elected a bunch of pro public option, anti individual mandate Democrats, only to get the opposite, presented to us as “reform”. Hell, a precious few of them were even supporting Single Payer, which is what we really need in my opinion.
The same thing happens when otherwise intelligent conservatives vote for Republicans, who promise them no nation building, smaller government, fiscal sanity and state’s rights. Then they get Reagan and the Bushes, and it’s more of the same. The true left and right in this country only exist on the fringe. They are never allowed anywhere near the real power.
Okay, rant over. Sorry to have posted such a long comment; I just needed to vent. To say I am disappointed would be an understatement. This country is dying, yet we are too damn proud/ignorant/frightened/whatever to admit it. As long as Congress and the Cabinet are revolving doors in and out of the corporate lobby, nothing will change for the better.
:/
P.S. – Your writeup is excellent, by the way. Thanks for doing so.
Wow, h_m! First of all, never apologize for long comments – even if you disagree with me.
To touch on what you commented on, I would also like to say that I love your “Red or Blue” example. A major effort I want to put into this site is to highlight what America did with its votes in 2008 and to try to show what it could do in the future. As this election cycle ramps up I will be spending more and more time encouraging people to continue to vote, despite their disillusion, and to vote third party. I want to take on some of the common arguments the status quo embeds within the debate that keeps us from doing that. If I can help people understand that it’s not an either/or option (You CAN have what’s not on the menu!) then I will be happy.
I agree when you talk about our country’s ultimate undoing. I hope that the situation is a hopeful one in which working people assume their role in government, but the present course is one that only leads to ruin as you’ve identified. Those in power want so badly to preserve a status quo that, as time goes by, the people are becoming more and more unhappy with. They keep applying band-aids but that will only stave off disaster for so long.
Thanks for your comments, I look forward to more.
You are now linked over at American Leftist. And, I put a post not too long ago going over some of the same terrain that you have here.
Thanks Richard, I try to make your blog a daily visit of mine. I linked you too as everyone should read A.L.